Call (844) NO-DISPUTESWhat is a Credit Card Association?
Credit card associations are massive organizations that create and enforce all the laws and steps that everyone has to follow whenever payment disputes come up and need to get handled.
Credit card associations like Visa and Mastercard don’t actually hand out cards to customers. They license their payment systems and branding to banks which then hand the cards out to customers – this detail matters quite a bit because when a customer pays with a card, a handful of different players are working behind the scenes and each one of them has a different job.
If a customer disputes a charge the laws come from the association, not the bank that issued the card. Chargeback response times get set by the association. They choose what counts as valid evidence to fight back. They choose which transactions get extra consumer protection.
These businesses create all the security standards that help stop fraud in the payment industry. Whenever you see new chip reader laws popping up at checkout or when businesses suddenly start asking customers for extra verification steps, that’s the payment card association working behind the scenes to tighten security. They need to make sure transactions stay safe without making the whole checkout process annoying for everyone. Merchants have to follow whatever laws and standards they set up so these decisions directly affect how we all pay for purchases every day.
Their payment system takes care of everything from refund processes to what customer information gets stored in their database.
How It Works
Credit card associations work just like a giant telephone switchboard that sits right in the middle of all the different banks and financial institutions. Every time a customer swipes their card at your store, the association has to connect your merchant bank with the customer’s issuing bank instantly and the whole transaction needs to happen within just a few seconds. It’s actually pretty amazing how fast the entire process moves along.
It’s fascinating how many different steps and security checks take place in the background to make that seemingly basic card swipe work the way it’s supposed to.
Laws that everyone in the payment world has to follow are also created by the associations. They have figured out how much time you get to respond to a chargeback dispute. They set the fees that your payment processor can charge you. They even list what information has to show up on your customer receipts. Every bank and merchant out there has to play by these laws if they want to be part of the credit card system at all.
Money has to move back and forth between different banks across the country and the associations take care of this. Your customer’s bank has to get money over to your bank somehow and the association makes sure it happens through their big payment network. Every transaction that goes through gets tracked and monitored to make sure the right amount of money ends up where it should – in the correct bank account.
Security standards also have to be managed by the associations and this is a big job. PCI compliance laws are built into the entire payment system and mean that the associations need every merchant and processor to keep card data completely safe. Every business has to follow very strict encryption standards and security protocols – no exceptions are allowed. Businesses that don’t meet these standards face quite harsh penalties. Big fines are involved and in the worst situations the associations can actually take away your ability to process credit cards altogether.
In the payment world, associations work like referees. They make sure that banks, merchants and payment processors follow the same playbook and step in whenever disputes come up between them.
How it Affects Chargeback Prevention
Credit card associations run the show for merchant chargebacks and each association has its own set of laws that merchants need to learn inside and out. Response times are a great example of just how different they can be – Visa gives merchants a comfortable 120 days to respond to any dispute. Mastercard puts merchants on a much tighter schedule with only 45 days to get their paperwork submitted. Reason codes are a whole other headache because they can vary quite a bit between the different associations. Something that Visa might label as “fraud” could get assigned a completely different code number from Mastercard for the exact same type of transaction problem.
A response template that works pretty well for a Visa chargeback won’t work for a Mastercard dispute – most merchants learn this the hard way and each card network has its own rules, timelines and documentation laws that can be very different. A quick win with Visa could backfire with Mastercard. These two businesses run completely different systems and each one wants to see different kinds of evidence to support your case. Separate strategies and documentation processes are necessary for each big card association if you want any actual shot at winning these disputes.
Card associations are already working behind the scenes to help stop chargebacks from becoming your headache in the first place. These organizations make merchants follow some pretty strict security standards (like PCI compliance) and use strong fraud-detection systems throughout their payment setups. Merchants who actually follow these laws see far fewer fraudulent transactions sneak through the system. That means you end up with a lot fewer chargebacks hitting your business down the road.
Most merchants run into issues when they can’t stay on top of all the association compliance laws and the penalties for falling behind are pretty harsh. Card associations monitor your chargeback ratios around the clock and they track every transaction while they watch those numbers very closely. Step over their acceptable thresholds and you’ll start seeing heavy fines appear on your monthly statements. Let those ratios climb any higher and they might shut down your merchant account completely. Businesses that depend on card payments face game over if they lose processing capabilities.
Card associations run the entire dispute-resolution process from start to finish and they want to make sure everyone knows who’s in charge. They choose what evidence you need to send, how it should be formatted and every deadline you’ll have to hit along the way. On top of all that, they’re also the ones who make the final call on who wins and who loses each dispute. This whole setup becomes even more frustrating because none of these terms are negotiable – you either learn to work within their system and do your best to succeed under their laws or you don’t get to participate at all.
Example Scenarios
Chargebacks are just a part of any e-commerce business and once one shows up in your inbox the clock starts ticking on your response. With Visa transactions, you get just 10 days to put together your response and send it back. It’s confusing because last month you had 14 days for that Mastercard dispute and the month before that the timeline was completely different again. Each card network uses its own set of deadlines and policies and you have to stay on top of each one if you want to keep everything under control. Merchants get confused by this all the time and it hurts your business. Missing even one deadline means that you’ll lose that dispute instantly – and there’s just no way around it once that happens.
Most merchants start having big problems when their chargeback numbers start climbing higher. Even if you’ve been doing everything right, your chargeback rate can still climb to something like 0.9 percent without much warning. At that point, you’re way too close to the 1 percent threshold which all the big card associations use as their official warning line. Cross over that number and the problems will start coming fast. Card networks will give you a high-danger label and charge you with penalty fees from every direction. Some payment processors might even stop working with you altogether if you stay above that threshold for too long.
Great news though – these same association laws can also work in your favor when you have the right plan. Think back to that suspicious order from last week (the one where the billing address didn’t match the cardholder’s information) and your payment system flagged it instantly because of the AVS laws. Sure – the customer complained about the extra verification steps. You avoided what could have been an expensive fraud chargeback down the road though. Security checks that the associations make merchants use actually protect you from disputes before they can even happen.
You still need to watch those thresholds because they can come up fast. One bad month in which a handful of customers dispute legitimate charges could easily push you over that 1 percent limit. Once that happens you’re looking at monthly fines that will usually start around $5,000 and only climb from there.
Requirements and Timeframes
Credit card businesses take deadlines seriously and merchants have to stay on top of them if they want to stay away from problems. Once a chargeback hits your account, you have to move very fast – you’ll usually get somewhere between 10 and 20 days to put your response together and submit it. Miss that deadline and the dispute is over before it even started – you lose it automatically. Each card network also has its own set of laws and timelines which makes the process more confusing than it needs to be. Visa could give you just 10 days to respond while Mastercard gives you a full 20 days for the exact same type of dispute.
Card networks are always keeping a close watch on your chargeback rates throughout the entire year and merchants who aren’t paying close attention find themselves in trouble. Most networks want you to keep your chargeback ratio well under 1% of your total transactions. Stay under that threshold and you’ll be fine. Cross over that line though and the penalties start adding up very fast – heavy fines, extra oversight fees and in the worst-case scenarios they can pull your ability to process credit cards altogether.
PCI compliance deadlines are another actual problem that can cost you if you miss them. Every merchant has to finish their annual security assessment and get it submitted by their due date. Deadlines change based on what level of merchant you are and which processor you work with so it’s not the same for everyone. Missing PCI compliance has severe consequences – if you’re not compliant during a data breach, the card networks can hit you with fines that could reach into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Visa and Mastercard also make it tougher by having completely different laws for just about everything. Even their chargeback reason codes are completely different and it gets frustrating to manage disputes. Something Visa labels as “fraud” could have a completely different code number and process over at Mastercard so you’re having to learn and work with two separate systems just to manage your chargebacks. Their monitoring programs have different names and different thresholds too. Visa calls theirs the “dispute monitoring program” while Mastercard runs something called the “excessive chargeback program” – it’s the same basic concept but with different laws and different consequences.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if a merchant violates credit card association rules?
Fines start at a few hundred dollars and go all the way to tens of thousands per violation and sadly that's just where the pain begins.
Once the card associations flag you as a troublesome merchant they'll put you on watch lists that come with much higher processing fees. These rate hikes can jump by a full percentage point or more with very little notice and they don't sound like much until you see how fast those extra costs add up when you have thousands of transactions every month.
Major violations mean you lose your ability to accept credit cards altogether. That's a death sentence for most modern businesses since customers expect to pay with plastic.
Card associations keep a close eye on chargeback ratios and once you cross their limits the penalties kick in instantly. Your dispute rights disappear and you face higher fines across the board. PCI compliance violations work the same way - fail to protect customer data and the consequences hit instantly.
This penalty system works like a trap designed to catch merchants and most business owners have no idea how fast the situation can get worse once they're in it. You lose your ability to dispute future chargebacks and it leaves you helpless when customers file claims against you. Your processing costs also increase permanently - you'll never see those old rates again. Some card types become completely off-limits for your business and the damage adds up. Getting back to normal is tough and can take months or even years.
How do credit card associations set chargeback liability rules?
Credit card associations are the ones who actually make the call on who gets stuck with the bill during a chargeback dispute. That choice can completely make or break your bottom line as a business owner, and each time a customer decides to dispute a transaction (for any reason at all) somebody still has to cover that financial loss at the end of the day. Most merchants have no idea that how you originally processed that payment determines who winds up having to pay for that loss.
EMV chip readers will actually protect you from most fraud-related chargebacks if you use them. Chip technology makes it much harder for criminals to create convincing counterfeit cards and if a fraudster somehow manages to use a fake card at your chip reader, the issuing bank usually picks up the cost instead of you. There's a catch though - you have to use the chip reader whenever there's a chip card. Swipe a chip card instead of inserting it and you lose all that liability protection, leaving you responsible for any fraudulent transactions.
Online transactions work very differently from a purchase made in your store. Major card companies created a tool called 3D Protected to help cut down on online fraud (you've probably seen this before - it's what runs "Verified by Visa" and "Mastercard SecureCode"). Customers have to prove who they are when they check out through this system and when they do, any disputes that pop up later can be pushed back to the customer's bank instead of becoming your problem. Without that extra step where they verify themselves, you're usually the one stuck paying for any chargebacks that show up.
These laws aren't set in stone either and it makes the whole situation even more frustrating for business owners to work their way through. Associations constantly update their policies whenever new tech comes out or when they see new fraud patterns crop up in the market. Whatever was protecting your business last year might not give you the same level of protection - this industry moves faster.
Your best strategy is to stay as up to date with whatever the associations are recommending and to actually follow their latest laws. Always use the chip reader if there's a chip card in front of you - no exceptions. Enable 3D Protected whenever it's available for online sales. You should also get proper authorization for each transaction that comes through your payment system. Every step you skip increases the odds that you'll wind up paying for those chargebacks directly out of your own business account.
Can merchants pick which credit card associations to accept?
Can merchants pick which credit card associations to accept?
Payment networks and their tough regulations become much easier to follow once you have the right foundation in place. Most merchants are accepting multiple card associations. It's hardly ever their choice, though. Payment processors usually bundle these networks together in package deals, so you get a lot of them.
These multiple network bundles get a bad reputation for being restrictive. They actually make your day-to-day business operations much easier, though. No more situations where you have to turn customers away because you can't process their card. It doesn't matter if they have Visa, Mastercard or American Express. Your customers get to pay in any way that they want and this flexibility almost always leads to better business results.
Hand-picking networks one by one usually creates far more problems than benefits. There's also the truth that customers expect to use their preferred cards no matter which association issued them. Savvy merchants learn the fee structures and chargeback regulations for each network that they accept, then fold those costs into their pricing and loss management plans.
You need to know in detail how each payment network hits your profits and how fast you can resolve disputes. Once you see what each network actually does for your business, you can reach more customers without turning your day-to-day operations into a mess.
Chargeback laws from multiple card associations can get quite tough because they call for more expertise and card businesses are always releasing regulation changes throughout the year that need tracking.
Leave a Reply